Atlantic Champ AAU 1941
Eastern Prep Champ 1940
Long Island (Section 8) Champion 1938-39
South Shore Athletic League Champion 1939
Captain Columbia University
| Dick Bensen '39
Atlantic Champ AAU 1941 Eastern Prep Champ 1940 Long Island (Section 8) Champion 1938-39 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1939 Captain Columbia University |
 | Jerry Liguori '39
Long Island Champion 1939 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1939 |
 | Don Moore '39
State Champion 1939 Long Island Champion 1939 |
 | Franklyn Muscara '39
State Champion 1939 |
 | Joe Pittelli '39
State Champion 1938 Long Island Champion 1938 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1938 |
 | Mario Pittelli '39
State Champion 1939 Long Island Champion 1938-39 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1938-39 |
 | Eddie Powers '39
State Champion 1938 Long Island Champion 1939 |
 | Pete Krutsch '40
State Champion 1939 Long Island Champion 1938-39-40 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1937-38-39-40 |
 | Bill Pelant '40
Long Island Champion 1940 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1940 |
 | Lou Schneider '40
Eastern Prep Champ 1941 State Champion 1939 Long Island Champion 1939-40 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1939-40 |
 | Frank Winter '40
State Champion 1939 Long Island Champion 1938-39-40-41 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1938-39-40-41 |
 | Henry "Hank" O'Shaughnessy '41
Captain Columbia University Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1947 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1942 Long Island Champion 1941 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1941 |
 | Bert wessman '41
Mid Altlantic Collegiate 1947 Long Island Champion 1941 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1941-42 |
 | Joe Creighton '42
Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1942 Long Island Champion 1941-42 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1941-42 |
 | Bill Kampfer '42
Long Island Champion 1942 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1942 |
 | Fred Korwan '42
Long Island Champion 1942 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1942 |
 | Bob Betzig '43
Captain Michigan Univ. 1949 Long Island Champion 1943 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1942 |
 | Dick Covell '43
Long Island Champion 1942 |
 | Henry Sheffield '43
Long Island Champion 1943 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1940-41-42-43 |
 | Herb Zoerner '43
Long Island Champion 1943 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1943 |
 | Harry Blanken '44
Long Island Champion 1944 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1943-44 |
 | Joe Golego '44
Captain Franklin & Marshall 1947-48 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1942 Long Island Champion 1942-43-44 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1941-42-43-44 |
 | Aldo Caperna '45
Long Island Champion 1945 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1945 |
 | Eric Erikson '46
Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1946 Long Island Champion 1945-46 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1945-46 |
| Richard Green '46
New York State AAU Champion 1947 Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1947 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1947 Long Island Champion 1946 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1946 |
 | Bob Mahoney '46
Southern Conference Champ 1948 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1946 Long Island Champion 1945-46 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1945-46 |
 | Pascal Perri '46
Captain Syracuse University 1950 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1948-49 Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1944 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1944 Long Island Champion 1943-44 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1943-44 National Wrestling Hall of Fame 1995 |
 | George Feuerbach '47
Captain Lehigh University 4th National AAU 1947-51-52 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1950-51-52 Outstanding Award 1952 NY State AAU Champion 1947 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1946 Long Island Champion 1947-48 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1947 |
 | Ken Hunte '47
Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1947 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1949-50 National Wrestling Hall of Fame 1999 |
 | Walt Sheffield '47
Long Island Champion 1947 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1946 |
 | Sam Cario '48
Captain Syracuse University 1950 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1948-49 Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1944 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1944 Long Island Champion 1943-44 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1943-44 |
 | John Caulfield '48
Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1948 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1948 Long Island Champion 1948 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1947-48 |
 | Joe Lemyre '48
National Collegiate 1952 3rd National Collegiate 1953 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1952 NY State AAU 1949 NY State AAU Champion 1949 Long Island Champion 1947-49 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1949 |
 | Ed Mahoney '48
Captain Lehigh 1953 Olympic Regionals 1952 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1949 Long Island Champion 1948-49 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1948-49 |
 | Bob Snyder '48
Atlantic AAU 1949 Long Island Champion 1948 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1948 |
 | Bob Bury '49
New York State Hall of Fame Captain Syracuse University 3rd National AAU 1955 Long Island Champion 1946-47-49 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1947-49 National Wrestling Hall of Fame 1997 |
 | Henry Gobetz '49
Long Island Champion 1950 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1949-50 |
 | Dick Lemyre '49
Pan American 1951 Captain Penn State 2nd National Collegiate 1953 3rd National Collegiate 1952 Eastern Intercollegiate Champion 1952-53-54 NY State AAU 1950 NY State AAU Champion 1949 Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1948-49-50 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1948 Long Island Champion 1948-49-50 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1948-49-50 |
 |
 | Harold Mahoney '49
National Junior AAU Champion 1950 South Cal AAU Champion 1950 Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion 1948 Long Island Champion 1947-48 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1947-48-49 |
 | Bob Brown '50
Mid-Atlantic AAU 1951 Long Island Champion 1950 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1950 |
 | Art Helf '50
South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion Long Island Champion (2 years) 4th National Intercollegiate |
 | Jim Mahoney '50
South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion (2 years) Long Island Champion (2 years) Captain Lehigh |
 | George Creason '51
South Shore Athletic League Champion Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion Long Island Champion State AAU Champion National AAU Champion |
 |
John DiMartino '51
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 | Bob Homan '51
South Shore Athletic League Champion Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion Long Island Champion (2 years) Captain Penn State Eastern Intercollegiate Champion |
 | Ken Hunt '51
South Shore Athletic League Champion Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion Long Island Champion (2 years) State AAU Champion Eastern Intercollegiate Champion |
 | Edwin Rooney '51
Junior Metropolitan AAU South Shore Athletic League Champion State AAU 2nd National AAU Regional Olympics Eastern Intercollegiate Outstanding Wrestler 2nd National Collegiate Captain Syracuse National Wrestling Hall of Fame 2000 |
 |
Frank Gobetz '52
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
Tom Brady '53
Long Island Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion (2 years) |
 | Dan Deppe '53
South Shore Athletic League Champion Junior Metropolitan AAU Senior Metropolitan AAU Long Island Champion (2 years) State AAU 4th National AAU 4th National Collegiate |
 |
Jerry Harrell '53
Mid-Atlantic Champion 1956 Long Island Champion 1953 South Shore Athletic League Champion 1952-53 |
 | Sidney Nodland '53
Junior Metropolitan AAU South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Senior Metropolitan AAU (2 years) Long Island Champion (3 years) State AAU Regional Olympics< BR>Eastern Intercollegiate National AAU |
 | Pat Zagarino '53 Junior Metropolitan AAU South Shore Athletic League Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Long Island Champion (2 years) Pennsylvania Teachers |
 |
Dick Dose '54
Long Island Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion (3 years) Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion |
 |
Ken Fisher '54
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
George Munnich '54
South Shore Athletic League Champion 1954 Senior Mets Champion 1957 NCAA Qualifier 1958 All-Navy Team 1960 Hawaii Freestyle Champion 1960 Greco-Roman All-American 1960 4th Place Olympic Trials 1960 Kings Point Hall of Fame 1990 National Wrestling Hall of Fame Lifetime |
 |
William Sandie '54
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
William Waples '54
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
William White '54
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
Ed Hawthorne '55
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Jerry Weisenseel '55
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Captain - West Point |
 |
Robert J. Dana '56
Metropolitan AA (AAU) '58, '59 South Shore Athletic League Champion SUNY Farmingdale 1959 Captain |
 |
Charles Bieber '57
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion Eastern Freshman Intercollegiate Champion |
 |
Tut Burtsell '57
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Fred Leich '57
Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
Herbert Bickel '58
Section 8 County Champion Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 | David Hayes '58 South Shore Athletic League Champion Section Eight Champion Long Island Champion |
 |
Mike Randall '58
Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion Long Island Champion New England Freshman Champion |
 |
Cliff Furrer '59
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) Long Island Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Jack Karp '59
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
Ray Nickla '59
County Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 | John "Denny" Ryan '59 South Shore Athletic League Champion Section Eight Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion |
 |
Gary Sirota '59
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Ronald Wieners '59
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Mark Piven '60
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) Long Island Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Nationals 3rd National Wrestling Hall of Fame 1997 |
 |
Don Werner '60
Section 8 County Champion Long Island Champion |
 |
Kenneth Long '62
Section 8 County Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Robert Porfidio '62
Section 8 County Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) |
 |
Mark DeMicco '63
Section 8 County Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 |
Robert Stock '63
Section 8 County Champion (2 years) South Shore Athletic League Champion (3 years) Eastern Freshman Champion |
 | Bill DeSario '64 Section Eight Champion New York State Champion Freshman Eastern Champion Metropolitan at CW Post (2 years) SUNYAC Wilkes (2 years) |
 | Tom Gleason '64 South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Section Eight Champion (2 years) New York State Champion |
 | Jack Paz '64 South Shore Athletic League Champion Section Eight Champion New York State Champion |
 |
Bob Waters '64
Section 8 County Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion |
 | Mike Fitzgerald '65 South Shore Athletic League Champion (2 years) Section Eight Champion Outstanding Wrestler Award New York State Champion Lindenhurst Invitational Champion Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Senior Metropolitan AAU Champion |
 | Alan Stock '67 South Shore Athletic League Champion (4 years) Junior Metropolitan AAU Champion Outstanding Wrestler Award Lindenhurst Invitational Champion SSAL Outstanding Wrestler Award Section Eight Champion (2 years) County Outstanding Wrestler New York State Champion (2 years) |
 |
Joe Savino '70
South Shore Athletic League Division Champion South Shore Champion Section 8 County Champion (2 years) 2nd NY State Champ |
 | Mike Muscara '71 S.S.A.L. Division Champion South Shore Champion Outstanding Wrestler Div. |
 |
Randy Ruth '75
Division Champion Nassua County Champion |
 |
John Schmidt '75
Massapequa Xmas Tournament Champion (3 years) Division Champion (3 years) Outstanding Wrestler Section 8 County Champion New York State 2nd place |
 | Lee Spiegel '76 Division Champion Massapequa X-Mass Champion (3 years) Tom Harvey Champion Nassau County Champion New York State Champion New England Champion (2 years) Maccabian Games Champion |
 | Anthony Diamiani '78 Division II Champion (2 years) Sprig Gardner Champion (2 years) Massapequa X-Mass Champion Tom Harvey Champion Nassau County Champion New York State Freestyle Champion Eastern Federation Champion |
 |
Anthony Conetta '79
Massapequa X-Mass Champion Conference 1-B Champion Sprig Gardner Champion Nassau County Champion South Shore Athletic League Champion S.U.N.Y Champion |
 |
Anthony Arena '80
Conference 1-3 Champion (2 years) Nassau County Champion Nassau County Outstanding Wrestler New York State 2nd place |
 |
Alan Amella '83
Division Champion (2 years) Massapequa X-Mass Champion Nassau County Champion |
 |
Chris Amella '83
Division Champion Sprig Gardner Champion (2 years) Suffern Champion (2 years) Nassau County Champion |
 | Mike Arena '84 Division Champion (2 years) Nassau County Champion (3 years) Outstanding Nassau County Wrestler New York State Champion (2 years) Massapequa X-Mass Champion (2 years) Suffern Champion (2 years) Outstanding New York State Wrestler |
 | Dennis Mejias '84 N.C.A.A.Division I All-American Division Champion (2 years) Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion Nassau County Champion (2 years) Massapequa X-Mass Champion New York State Champion |
 | Glenn Rommel '87" Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion (4 years) Qualifying Tournament Champion(3 years) County Tournament Champion (2 years) Massapequa Tournament Champion New York State 2nd & 6th |
 | Bob Carillo '88 Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion (2 years) Qualifying Tournament Champion(2 years) County Tournament Champion |
 | Keith Rommel '88 Massapequa Tournament Champion (3 years) Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion (2 years) Locust Valley Tournament Champion Syosset Tournament Champion Qualifying Tournament Champion (2 years) County Tournament Champion New York State 5th |
 |
John Caspers '91
Massapequa Champion Sprig Gardner Champion Locust Valley Champion Nassau County Champion Qualifying Champion (2 years) New York State Champion 6th place |
 |
John Pinto '96
Massapequa Champion (2 years) Sprig Gardner Champion (2 years) Locust Valley Champion (2 years) Qualifying Champion County Champion |
 | Mike McCann '98 Locust Valley Tournament Champion (2 years) Division Qualifier Champion (2 years) Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion (2 years) Massapequa Tournament Champion Southside Tournament Champion Nassau County Champion (2 years) |
 | Jody Green '99 Locust Valley Tournament Champion (2 years) Division Qualifier Champion Sprig Gardner Tournament Champion Nassau County Champion New York State - Fastest Pin National H.S. Coaches Association: All American National H.S. Coaches Association: Academic All-American |
